Direction for us in that New Testament letter.
Imagine Paul in prison, probably in Rome. His co-workers are allowed to bring him food and to assist him with his writing projects. You know some of them: Mark and Luke are with him. So is a man named Epaphras. (Colossians 4:10, 12, 14)
One Day Epaphras brings along someone from his hometown he may have found out on the streets of Rome: a man named Onesimus. Onesimus keeps coming back day after day, listening to Paul speak about the Lord, and eventually confesses faith in Jesus. Paul later calls him someone he brought to faith, writing “whom I begot in prison” (Philemon 10). Onesimus becomes a valuable assistant to Paul, who calls him a “faithful and beloved brother” (Colossians 4:9).
Sometime later Onesimus makes an embarrassing personal confession to Paul. He says he is a runaway slave, and moreover that he stole money from his master as he was fleeing. When Paul is told that the master’s name is Philemon, Paul recognizes him as someone he knew and had given help in the past (Paul says about Philemon, “not to mention that you owe me your very self” in Philemon 19).
Paul makes clear to Onesimus that the right thing to do is to return to his master. Paul is putting the final touches on a letter he was about to send to the church in Philemon’s home town of Colossae. Paul decides to send Onesimus along with the man who was going to deliver the letter, named Tychicus, and gave Onesimus a personal note to hand to Philemon (Colossians 4:7-9).
As you read Philemon, imagine that you are Onesimus standing quivering with fear in front of your master as you hand him the note, aware that the slave-master with his whip has probably already been summoned. All you can depend on is the strategy Paul has used in the letter to complement Philemon as a man of faith before he asks him to have mercy on his runaway. Read the opening of the letter in Philemon verses 1 to 7.
Read Paul’s personal appeal to Philemon in verses 8 to 10, noting it is based on love.
Verse 11 is a side-note based on a pun. The name Onesimus means “useful,” so Paul remarks that though Onesimus had not lived up to his name in the past, but after becoming a Christian he was of much use to Paul in prison, and can now be useful to Philemon by providing a challenge to Philemon’s faith and an opportunity to exercise Christian love.
In verses 12 to 14 note how careful Paul is not to order Philemon what to do, but to rely on Philemon’s Christian love to come into play. Paul goes further in verses 15 and 16, asking Paul to regard Philemon as a brother in Christ. Paul has not forgotten about the stolen money, and covers it in verses 17 to 19.
Paul’s final appeal in verses 20 and 21 to have mercy on Onesimus is based on Philemon’s love for Paul, since Paul knows that this love comes from the work of Christ in Philemon’s heart.
In verse 22 we see Paul’s faith that the Lord will bring about his release from prison. Paul was indeed released from prison and continued traveling, writing to Timothy from Macedonia (1 Timothy 1:3). Paul ends the letter by sending greetings from the same list of those who are with him that he named at the end of the letter to all the Colossians. (Philemon verses 23-25).
One lesson for us in this short note to Philemon is the difference between coercion and voluntary action. Philemon would have had a legal right to punish Onesimus, both as a runaway and as a thief. Paul is asking Philemon to give up this right. This is in line with the motivation asked of all Christians in Philippians chapter 2. Verse 4 there tells us to put the interests of others above our own interests because that is what Jesus did. Verse 5 tells us to model our attitude upon Jesus, who willingly set aside his divine prerogatives (verse 6). Jesus emptied himself, brought himself down to the level of a slave, and became a human (verse 7). He obeyed God’s plan to die as a ransom for our sins, and Revelation 5:9 tells us that by his blood Jesus purchased us to be in God’s kingdom.
This principle of being willing to give up rights is confirmed by Paul in 1 Corinthians 9:12, where he speaks of having a right but not making use of it for the sake of a larger purpose. There were to be sure times when Paul did insist on his rights as a Roman citizen, for example by exercising his right to appeal to Caesar when his hearings before the local governors were dragging on without resolution. But in other circumstances he did not exercise his rights. How do we know which to do?
When we are wronged, we experience our old life (which thinks the same way as an unbeliever) urging us to “stand up for our rights” and “get back at” the one who wronged us. But we also have a new life, which is prompting us to give up our rights for the sake of a higher purpose. What is this higher purpose? In 1 Corinthians 9:12 Paul explains “we put up with anything rather than hinder the gospel of Christ.” What matters is the salvation of the person who has wronged us, and that informs our decision about how best to react.
Another lesson in Philemon has to do with slavery. The Bible has been criticized because it does not command the abolishment of slavery. In Philemon Paul explicitly says about freeing the slave Philemon “I want your act of kindness to come from your heart, and not be something you feel forced to do.” (Contemporary English Translation of verse 14). Making a command does not guarantee that it be obeyed, but a change of heart brings a lasting transformation.
Slavery continued on for almost 2000 more years. But the letter to Philemon was never omitted from the Bible during all that time. In the 1800’s the importance of freeing slaves finally bore fruit. Public opinion within Christendom provided a covering for governments to abolish slavery, first in England, and finally in America.
Do you wonder why this short note was copied year after year, and never failed to be included in all the manuscript collections of Paul’s letters? The answer might be in a letter written by a Christian leader named Ignatius (35-107 AD) whch mentions a man he knew named Onesimus and describes him as a “man of inexpressible love” and as the bishop of Ephesus. We don’t know if it was the same Onesimus, but if it was that might be a reason why the letter was treasured and continually recopied as an exemplar for the Christian life. We are thankful to God that it was preserved for us.
Written by Jim Found, 11/3/26. Go to Bible Introduction menu
To see the main menu of this site click on the page title Personal Growth Resources.
References used: Lutheran Bible Companion Volume 2, St. Louis, Concordia Publishing house: 2014, pages 595-8 and 636ff.
New Bible Dictionary, Downers Grove Illinois, Intervarsity Press, 1962, article Onesimus.
Oxford Concise Dictionary of the Christian Church, Oxford UK, 2000, article Ignatius.